Medicare OEP: An Agent’s Guide to Success, Compliance, and Client Trust

The Medicare Open Enrollment Period (OEP) is a valuable yet often misunderstood opportunity for agents to assist clients. While the Annual Enrollment Period (AEP) receives the lion’s share of attention, OEP offers unique opportunities to further support clients and build trust—if used wisely and ethically. Let’s dive into what OEP is, how agents can maximize it, and the key compliance rules to follow.

What is Medicare OEP?

The Medicare Open Enrollment Period runs from January 1 to March 31 each year. Unlike AEP, which is focused on adding new enrollees, OEP allows existing Medicare Advantage (MA) enrollees to switch plans or revert to Original Medicare.

During OEP, clients can:

• Switch from one Medicare Advantage plan to another.
• Drop Medicare Advantage and return to Original Medicare, with the option to add a standalone Part D plan.

However, clients cannot:

• Join a Medicare Advantage plan if they’re already enrolled in Original Medicare.
• Switch from one standalone Part D plan to another.
• Make multiple plan changes (only one change is allowed during OEP).

Statistic: According to CMS, approximately 3 million Medicare beneficiaries make changes during OEP, highlighting its impact.

Dos and Don’ts During OEP

Staying compliant and respectful is critical. Here are some clear-cut dos and don’ts to guide your work with clients during this period.

Do: Educate Your Clients

Provide helpful, neutral information that empowers clients to make the right decision for their needs.

“Education is key. When clients know they can trust you to prioritize their well-being over a sale, they’re more likely to remain loyal.”

1. Review Benefits - Offer to go over your clients’ current benefits and see if they’re aligned with their evolving healthcare needs.
2. Address Pain Points - Listen carefully to your clients’ frustrations or concerns about their current plan (e.g., higher costs, network limitations, or coverage gaps) to see if there’s a better option.

Don’t: Engage in Prohibited Marketing Practices

CMS regulations are strict during OEP. Don’t initiate contact for the sole purpose of encouraging plan changes.

Important Reminder: “Medicare’s guidelines are designed to protect the consumer. Follow the rules, and you’ll foster trust that translates into long-term relationships.”

• No Unsolicited Contact: Don’t cold-call clients or run advertising specifically targeting OEP plan changes.
• No Aggressive Sales Tactics: Avoid pressuring clients to switch plans; instead, allow them to make changes only if they feel it will benefit them.

Do: Keep Conversations Client-Centered

Emphasize that OEP is about ensuring clients feel confident in their coverage, not just about switching plans.

Quote from a Successful Agent: “Some of my best client relationships have been built during OEP by focusing on what’s best for them, even if that means no change.”

• Offer Honest Feedback: If a client’s current plan meets their needs, be transparent and advise them to stay where they are.
• Create Checkpoints: Let your clients know they can reach out to you for support beyond just enrollment periods. Building trust year-round reinforces your role as a partner in their healthcare decisions.

Don’t: Focus Only on Switching Plans

Avoid using OEP as an opportunity to push unnecessary plan changes. Instead, use it as a time to address questions and assess whether any adjustments would actually be beneficial.

• Avoid Over-Promising Savings - Don’t over-emphasize savings unless you can ensure the new plan will indeed lower costs without sacrificing needed coverage.
• Don’t Ignore the Bigger Picture - Changes may impact other aspects of your client’s healthcare, so it’s crucial to consider their entire health profile and financial situation.

Compliance Tips for Agents During OEP

Ensuring compliance during OEP is not just a legal requirement; it’s a best practice for sustaining a reputable business. Here’s how to stay compliant:

1. Review CMS Marketing Regulations
   Agents must avoid initiating contact with clients specifically for the purpose of plan changes during OEP. Make sure your communications are CMS-compliant and adhere to the rules surrounding OEP.

2. Reinforce the Value of Client-Requested Changes
   Always let clients come to you with changes they’re interested in exploring rather than proactively reaching out about switching plans.

3. Documentation and Record-Keeping
   Keep detailed records of every interaction to demonstrate transparency and compliance with CMS guidelines. Document reasons for plan changes to show that recommendations align with client needs and requests.

4. Avoid Any Messaging That Could Be Seen as “Inducing” Changes
   All communication should remain neutral. Avoid language that could seem to encourage switching purely for financial gain or to promote one particular plan.

Leveraging OEP to Build Long-Term Client Relationships

While compliance is essential, OEP is also an opportunity to strengthen client relationships. It’s a time when clients may feel uncertain about their coverage, so being available to address questions, provide clarity, and offer support can foster trust and loyalty.

Client Retention Strategies During OEP

1. Annual Check-In Calls
   Although you can’t cold-call to discuss OEP, setting up annual reviews during AEP can give clients a chance to consider potential changes during OEP.

2. Educational Content
   Offer materials that explain what clients can (and cannot) do during OEP. Highlight the limited nature of OEP so they understand the importance of thoughtful decision-making.

3. Use Client Testimonials
   Share anonymized stories from clients who have successfully navigated plan changes during OEP to illustrate how you provide value.

4. Provide a “Medicare Coverage Checklist”
   This tool helps clients evaluate if they’re in the right plan and can serve as a guide for your conversation. If they realize they need a change, they’ll be more likely to reach out to you.

Agent Insight: “I don’t view OEP as a time to push for sales. Instead, it’s a time to check in with clients and show them I’m here to help, even if it’s just to confirm they’re in the best plan.”

Statistics and Facts: Why OEP Matters

• Retention Focused: Studies indicate that agents who engage with clients during OEP build greater loyalty, with 70% of clients who make a plan change during OEP sticking with the same agent the following year.
• Client Satisfaction Impact: Medicare beneficiaries with informed agents report 30% higher satisfaction with their plan choices.
• Opportunity for Education: Nearly 40% of Medicare Advantage clients report feeling uncertain about their plan at the start of each year, showcasing a need for agent support.

A Checklist for Navigating OEP

Here’s a quick checklist for agents to reference as they navigate OEP:

• Educate Clients – Provide unbiased information and let them know you’re available for questions.
• Avoid Prohibited Outreach – Only discuss OEP if the client initiates the conversation.
• Maintain Compliance – Document all interactions and ensure recommendations are truly in the client’s best interest.
• Build Trust with Transparency – When discussing options, give honest feedback on why a client should stay with their current plan or explore a new one.
• Follow-Up Plan – Schedule a mid-year check-in for all clients as part of your service model.

Conclusion: Building Trust and Growing Your Business During OEP

OEP presents an opportunity for agents to reinforce their commitment to doing what’s best for clients. By focusing on client needs, staying compliant, and using this period to educate and support, agents can foster loyalty, build trust, and ultimately grow their business. Rather than pushing for changes, view OEP as a time to serve clients’ best interests, knowing that this approach will lead to referrals, repeat business, and a reputation as a reliable, trustworthy Medicare expert.

Final Thought: “Helping clients understand their choices and make the best decision for their needs will always be the heart of our work as agents. Success comes naturally when clients know you genuinely care about their well-being.”

View our Medicare Solutions page