Comprehensive Agent Guide for Medicare Compliance

Compliance is the backbone of a successful Medicare sales career. It's what protects your clients, your business, and your reputation. Yet, staying compliant can sometimes feel like navigating a minefield of rules and regulations. Fear not—this guide combines practical best practices with the latest updates to help you stay on the right side of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) while growing your Medicare business.

With this all-inclusive guide, you’ll gain valuable insights and actionable tips for navigating compliance confidently and effectively.

Why Compliance is Non-Negotiable

Compliance is about doing the right thing for your clients while avoiding fines, legal repercussions, or even losing your license. Here's why it's essential:

• Client Protection: Ensures clients are not misled or mistreated.
• Avoid Penalties: CMS fines can range from hundreds to thousands of dollars for non-compliance.
• Build Trust: Clients are more likely to work with agents who are ethical and transparent.

Stat: In 2022, CMS issued over $1 million in fines for compliance violations in Medicare marketing.

Top Compliance Best Practices

1. Understand Medicare Marketing Guidelines (MMG)

The Medicare Communications and Marketing Guidelines (MCMG) are the rulebook for Medicare sales. A few key takeaways:

• No Misleading Statements: Avoid terms like "free" or "best" unless backed by factual, CMS-approved data.
• Pre-Approved Materials Only: Use only CMS or carrier-approved marketing materials.
• No Unsolicited Contacts: Cold calls, door-to-door visits, and unrequested emails are prohibited.

Pro Tip: Bookmark the CMS.gov Medicare Guidelines for easy access to the latest updates.

2. Follow Third-Party Marketing Organization (TPMO) Rules

CMS considers agents and brokers third-party marketing organizations (TPMOs).

Here's what’s required:

• Keep a list of vendors, contractors, and subcontractors involved in marketing or enrollment.
• Obtain prior written consent before sharing beneficiary data.
• Use the required TPMO disclaimer on marketing materials and sales calls:
  

  “We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently, we represent [number] organizations which offer [number] products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Program (SHIP) for all options.”

3. Secure Permission to Contact (PTC)

Before reaching out to prospects, you need documented permission to contact.

This can be collected via:

• Business Reply Cards (BRCs): Flyers or mailers that include a form for clients to request contact.
• Compliant Emails: Emails must include an opt-out option and avoid steering clients toward specific plans.

4. Master the Scope of Appointment (SOA)

An SOA outlines the specific topics you’ll discuss during a meeting.

Here’s how to stay compliant:

• When to Collect: An SOA must be signed 48 hours before a meeting, except for walk-ins or urgent cases.
• Keep Records: Retain SOA forms for at least 10 years, even if no sale occurs.
• Stay On-Topic: If a client asks about services outside the SOA, you must complete a new form before proceeding.

Example: During a meeting, if a client asks about life insurance, you must schedule a new appointment to discuss non-health-related products.

5. Record Marketing and Sales Calls

Agents must record all marketing, sales, and enrollment calls. These recordings must include:

• Introductory calls to educate clients.
• Follow-up calls for enrollment.
• Retention calls aimed at keeping clients in their current plans.

Pro Tip: Use reliable call recording software to ensure full compliance. Check out our blog on the Top Call Recording Applications for recommendations.

Key Compliance Areas

HIPAA Compliance

As an insurance agent, you're responsible for safeguarding protected health information (PHI). Best practices include:

• Avoid sharing PHI via unsecured emails or voicemails.
• Always use encrypted systems for storing or transmitting sensitive data.

Marketing Rules

Agents must wait until October 1 to market the next year’s plans and October 15 to begin enrolling clients. Key points:

• Avoid absolutes like "free" or "best."
• Include disclaimers for $0 premiums, explaining that other costs may apply.
• Use CMS-approved materials for plan-specific benefits.

Events and Presentations

Compliance extends to how you handle events, whether educational or sales-focused:

Educational Events

• Do: Provide general Medicare information and distribute non-specific educational materials.
• Don’t: Discuss plan-specific details or collect contact information.

Sales Events

• Do: Collect enrollment forms and provide plan-specific details using pre-approved materials.
• Don’t: Require attendees to sign in or offer cash incentives.

Real-Life Compliance Scenarios

Scenario 1: The Well-Intentioned Agent

Agent: “This is the best plan in your area.” Client: “Great! Let’s enroll.”

Why It's Non-Compliant: The agent used the word "best," which is prohibited unless backed by verifiable data. Instead, the agent should say: Agent: “This plan offers strong benefits that may align well with your needs.”

Scenario 2: The Overeager Marketer

Agent: Sends unsolicited text messages to prospects.

Why It’s Non-Compliant: Texts are considered unsolicited contact. Instead, the agent should use compliant email marketing with an opt-out option.

Best Practices for Staying Compliant

1. Stay Organized: Use a CRM to manage PTCs, SOAs, and call recordings.
2. Leverage Training: Attend webinars and courses to stay updated on CMS regulations.
3. Double-Check Materials: Ensure all marketing materials are pre-approved by CMS or carriers.
4. Ask Questions: When in doubt, consult with your FMO or carrier compliance department.

Compliance is Your Compass

Compliance isn’t just about following rules—it’s about ensuring your clients trust you and receive accurate, ethical advice. It’s the foundation of a successful Medicare sales career.

At PSM Brokerage, we’re here to make compliance easier for you. From training resources to customizable, compliant marketing materials through our PSM Marketing Hub, we provide the tools and guidance you need to grow your business while staying compliant.

Do’s and Don’ts for Insurance Agents

Do’s

• Follow CMS Guidelines: Always adhere to the Medicare Communications and Marketing Guidelines (MCMG) and other CMS regulations.
• Use CMS-Approved Marketing Materials: Ensure all promotional materials are reviewed and approved by CMS, including plan-specific content.
• Obtain Permission to Contact (PTC): Secure explicit consent before reaching out to potential clients.
• Secure a Scope of Appointment (SOA): Obtain and document an SOA before discussing specific plans.
• Record Marketing and Sales Calls: Record all calls related to marketing, enrollment, or retention in their entirety and retain them for at least 10 years.
• Provide Required Disclaimers: Include the appropriate TPMO disclaimers in communications, marketing materials, and during sales calls.
• Maintain Confidentiality: Protect client information in compliance with HIPAA and CMS privacy standards.
• Stay Educated: Keep up with annual certifications, training, and updates to Medicare compliance rules.
• Disclose Plan Availability: If you don’t offer all plans in an area, disclose this to potential clients and direct them to resources like Medicare.gov.
• Document Everything: Retain SOAs, call recordings, and compliance-related documents for at least 10 years.
• Be Transparent: Provide accurate and clear information about plan options, benefits, and costs without exaggeration or misleading statements.

Don’ts

• Avoid Unsolicited Contact: Do not cold call, visit, or approach potential clients without prior permission.
• No Misleading Language: Avoid using terms like "free" or "best" when describing plans, unless explicitly permitted.
• Don’t Pressure Clients: Do not coerce or unduly influence clients into making decisions.
• No Door-to-Door Sales: Agents are prohibited from knocking on doors or soliciting in common areas.
• Skip Plan Comparisons Without Approval: Do not compare one plan to another without carrier consent and supporting data.
• Avoid Cross-Selling: Refrain from promoting non-health-related products during Medicare sales or appointments.
• Don’t Omit Required Disclaimers: Ensure all communications, especially marketing materials, include the required disclaimers verbatim.
• Don’t Conduct Unapproved Marketing: All events, presentations, and materials must align with CMS regulations and carrier guidelines.
• No Inaccurate Claims: Refrain from making guarantees or unsubstantiated statements about coverage, costs, or benefits.
• Don’t Collect SOAs Inappropriately: Ensure SOAs are voluntary and properly documented.

View Agent Compliance page

Ready to take the next step?
Partner with PSM Brokerage today and unlock a world of resources, support, and opportunities to elevate your Medicare business—compliantly!

Download in PDF