Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Creating an Effective Workflow: From Prospecting to Follow-Up

January 7th, 2025

3 min read

By www.psmbrokerage.com Admin

Creating an Effective Workflow: From Prospecting to Follow-Up
5:19

Streamlining Your Insurance Sales

A structured sales process is the backbone of any successful insurance business. By streamlining workflows, agents can save time, convert more prospects, and retain clients for the long haul. This guide breaks down an efficient workflow for insurance agents, covering every stage from prospecting to follow-up, with actionable tips to implement immediately.

Introduction: Why a Workflow is Essential

The insurance industry is fast-paced and competitive, and agents need a systematic approach to stay ahead. A well-defined workflow ensures that every client interaction is purposeful and that no leads slip through the cracks. As Zig Ziglar said, “You don’t have to be great to start, but you have to start to be great.”

Step 1: Prospecting

✔️ Strategies for Finding Leads

Prospecting is the foundation of your workflow. Without a steady stream of leads, growth stagnates.

Here’s how to build a robust prospecting pipeline:

✔️ Tools to Streamline Prospecting

Step 2: Initial Contact

✔️ Crafting Your Approach

Your first interaction sets the tone. Whether through a phone call, email, or in-person meeting:

  • Be personable and professional.
  • Clearly communicate your value proposition.
  • Focus on how your expertise can solve their specific problems.

✔️ Handling Objections

Common objections include cost concerns or skepticism about the necessity of coverage. Overcome these by:

  • Sharing relatable success stories.
  • Providing clear comparisons that show value.
  • Empathizing with their concerns while confidently addressing them.

Step 3: Needs Analysis

✔️ Asking the Right Questions

This stage is critical for building trust and tailoring your recommendations. Key questions include:

  • “What are your biggest concerns about healthcare costs?”
  • “Do you currently have coverage, and what do you like/dislike about it?”
  • “Do you have any long-term financial goals we should consider?”

✔️ Tools for Needs Assessments

  • Quoting Platforms: Tools like HealthSherpa for ACA plans or Sunfire for Medicare allow for side-by-side comparisons tailored to client needs.
  • Insurance Needs Calculators: Use calculators to assess life insurance needs based on income, debt, and future expenses.

Step 4: Tailored Recommendations

✔️ Presenting Solutions Effectively

Once you’ve identified their needs, present options clearly and confidently:

  • Keep it Simple: Avoid overwhelming clients with too many choices.
  • Show Value: Highlight how each option addresses their specific concerns.
  • Be Transparent: Explain costs, benefits, and limitations honestly.

✔️ Leveraging Technology for Customization

Use tools like quoting platforms to present personalized options in real-time. Digital presentations or virtual meetings can also make it easy to explain complex plans.

Step 5: Closing the Sale

✔️ Tips for Securing the Commitment

Closing is often the most challenging part, but it doesn’t have to be:

  • Use Trial Closes: “Does this plan align with your needs?” helps gauge readiness.
  • Create Urgency: Mention deadlines like Open Enrollment or limited-time offers.
  • Ask for the Sale: Confidently ask, “Are you ready to move forward with this coverage?”

✔️ Overcoming Final Hurdles

Address last-minute objections with empathy and facts. If they need more time, schedule a follow-up call to keep the momentum going.

Step 6: Post-Sale Follow-Up

✔️ Strengthening Client Relationships

Your work doesn’t end once the sale is closed. Building long-term relationships ensures client retention and referrals:

  • Send a thank-you email or handwritten note.
  • Provide a welcome packet with plan details and contact information.
  • Offer to review their coverage annually.

✔️ Cross-Selling and Referrals

Post-sale follow-ups are perfect opportunities for cross-selling and requesting referrals:

  • Suggest ancillary products like dental, vision, or hospital indemnity insurance.
  • Ask satisfied clients to refer friends or family members who might benefit from your services.

🏁  Bringing It All Together


A structured workflow helps agents focus on what matters most: building trust, meeting client needs, and growing their business. By implementing these steps, you’ll save time, increase conversions, and establish a reputation as a knowledgeable, reliable insurance advisor.

Contact us today to learn how we can help you streamline your workflow, increase sales, and build lasting client relationships. Let’s grow together!

Visit the PSM Learning Center

*For agent use only. Not affiliated with the U. S. government or federal Medicare program. This website is designed to provide general information on Insurance products, including Annuities. It is not, however, intended to provide specific legal or tax advice and cannot be used to avoid tax penalties or to promote, market, or recommend any tax plan or arrangement. Please note that PSM Brokerage, its affiliated companies, and their representatives and employees do not give legal or tax advice. Encourage your clients to consult their tax advisor or attorney.